Lake with whispy clouds

Cagles Mill Lake Vacation Rentals

Cagles Mill Lake

Show on map
Cagles Mill Lake
Show on map

Why Rent On Cagles Mill Lake

Cagles Mill Lake, situated in southern Putnam County, Indiana, is a vibrant hub of outdoor adventure and natural beauty. This 1,400-acre lake, fed by Mill Creek, is a central attraction within the expansive Lieber State Recreation Area. Here, adventure travelers can indulge in a variety of activities such as boating, fishing, and even waterskiing, with two launch ramps and a marina offering boat rentals and supplies.

For those seeking wellness and connection with nature, the area boasts numerous hiking trails, including the Covered Bridge Nature Trail, a moderate .75-mile path featuring a stoned trail, benches, and a picturesque covered bridge. The lake is also a haven for eagle watchers, with a notable bald eagle’s nest that attracts visitors from across the country.

Families will find plenty to enjoy with the Aquatic Center’s zero-entrance pool, water bubblers, and a thrilling tornado water slide, open during the summer months. Additional amenities include playgrounds, basketball courts, horseshoe pits, and picnic areas. The nearby Cataract Falls, a stunning natural landmark, adds to the area’s allure, making Cagles Mill Lake an ideal destination for diverse travelers seeking both action and tranquility.

Best time to go
Visit Cagles Mill Lake in late spring, particularly May, when the blooms burst forth and the warm sun gently kisses the water’s surface. Embrace tranquil fishing as the lake awakens, with ample opportunities for kayaking amidst serene surroundings, all before the summer crowds arrive.
Water Quality
Cagles Mill Lake's water exhibits a deep blue hue, reflecting its substantial depth and the surrounding forested landscape. The water clarity is typically murky, often appearing cloudy or silty, especially after rainfall, due to the high levels of suspended sediment.
Surface area (mi)
3.54
Max depth (ft)
50
Elevation (ft)
636.48
Shoreline length (mi)
38.15

Popular activities

  • Boating
  • Kayaking
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • Hiking
pencil

Information not accurate?

Help us improve by making a suggestion.

Nearby lakes

Frequently Asked Questions

Ready to dive into what Cagles Mill Lake has to offer? Let’s tackle some of the burning questions you might have as you plan your visit!

  • Yes, you can swim in Cagles Mill Lake, but only from Memorial Day through Labor Day. The swimming area is clearly marked and located inside Lieber State Recreation Area.

  • Cagles Mill Lake is a popular destination because it offers various recreational activities. The lake is suitable for boating, tubing, kayaking, and fishing, with an abundance of fish species. It also features a bald eagle’s nest, Cataract Falls, and amenities like a marina, campgrounds, and hiking trails.

  • For Cagles Mill Lake in Indiana, the bag limits and size restrictions vary by species. For black bass, the daily limit is 5 fish with a minimum size of 14 inches. For crappie, the limit is 25 fish with no minimum size. Catfish have no daily limit or minimum size, but other species like walleye and sauger have specific limits and sizes depending on the location.

  • Yes, there is a public beach at Cagles Mill Lake, located inside Lieber State Recreation Area. Swimming is permitted from Memorial Day through Labor Day. The beach area is part of the larger recreation facilities available at the lake.

  • Towns near Cagles Mill Lake include Greencastle, Terre Haute, and Martinsville. The lake is located in Putnam and Owen counties, approximately midway between Indianapolis and Terre Haute. These towns are within a reasonable driving distance from the lake.