Lake with small bridge

Lake Shafer Vacation Rentals

Lake Shafer

Why Rent On Lake Shafer

Lake Shafer, a serene and vibrant destination in Monticello, Indiana, offers an array of activities and attractions that cater to adventure seekers, wellness enthusiasts, and family travelers alike. This lakeside haven is home to the iconic Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Park, where visitors can embark on thrilling roller coasters, enjoy leisurely sky rides, and explore an array of kid-friendly attractions. The water park, open daily from May to September, features a lazy river, splash pad, and multiple water slides, ensuring fun for all ages.

For those inclined towards outdoor adventures, Lake Shafer is a hotspot for fishing and water sports. Anglers can cast their lines in hopes of catching largemouth bass, bluegill, and catfish, while water sports enthusiasts can rent Waverunners or pontoon boats to explore the lake’s expansive surface.

Surrounding the lake are historical treasures, including guided tours of ancient caves carved out over millennia, offering a unique glimpse into the area’s natural history. Nearby, the Tall Timbers Marina and Whyte Horse Winery provide additional points of interest for those looking to combine adventure with relaxation and local culture. Whether you’re seeking adrenaline-pumping activities or serene natural beauty, Lake Shafer is an idyllic destination that promises unforgettable experiences.

Best time to go
As summer unfolds, June to early September invites sun-soaked days on Lake Shafer, where water sports reign supreme. Embrace tranquil mornings fishing, then savor the vibrant atmosphere during mid-July's Shafer Lake Festival, a perfect fusion of leisure and local charm.
Water Quality
Lake Shafer's water exhibits a deep blue hue, reflecting its mesotrophic status with moderate nutrient levels. The water clarity is ultra-clear, offering sparkling, see-through conditions ideal for recreational activities.
Surface area (mi)
3.24
Max depth (ft)
29.99
Elevation (ft)
626.64
Shoreline length (mi)
50

Popular activities

  • Boating
  • Waterskiing
  • Kayaking
  • Canoeing
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • Hiking
  • Jet Skiing
pencil

Information not accurate?

Help us improve by making a suggestion.

Marinas on Lake Shafer

Nearby lakes

Frequently Asked Questions

Ready to dive into what Lake Shafer has to offer? Let’s tackle some of the burning questions you might have as you plan your visit!

  • Yes, there are health and safety precautions to take when swimming in Lake Shafer. Always enter the water feet first to avoid hidden hazards, and be cautious of water conditions such as temperature, depth, and currents. Wear appropriate safety gear, including life jackets, especially when engaging in water sports.

  • Lake Shafer is a popular destination because of its abundant recreational opportunities. The lake offers fishing for various fish species, including largemouth bass and catfish, and is ideal for water sports like kayaking and speedboating. Additionally, its banks feature nature trails and spots for sunbathing and fishing, making it a haven for both wildlife and outdoor activities.

  • For Lake Shafer in Indiana, the daily bag limits and size restrictions vary by species. For black bass (largemouth, smallmouth, and spotted), the daily bag limit is 5 fish, with no fish between 12 to 15 inches kept and no more than two fish over 15 inches. For white bass and hybrid striped bass, the limit is 12 fish, with no more than two exceeding 17 inches. Bluegill and redear sunfish have no minimum size limits, but check specific exceptions. Catfish have various size and bag limits, such as no more than one blue catfish over 35 inches and one channel catfish over 28 inches.

  • The best beach at Lake Shafer for families is Honey Creek Bay. It offers calm waters ideal for kayaking, paddleboarding, and swimming, making it a delightful spot for families to enjoy a day of aquatic fun. The area is also peaceful and surrounded by lush greenery, providing a relaxing environment.

  • Towns near Lake Shafer include Monticello, Logansport, Brookston, and Chalmers, all located in White County, Indiana. These towns are close to the lake and offer various amenities and services for visitors and residents. Monticello is the largest town in the area and sits between Lake Shafer and Lake Freeman.