Lake and lily pads

Merrill Creek Reservoir Vacation Rentals

Hike the clear blue shoreline trails with your family at Merrill Creek Reservoir near the town of Stewartsville, New Jersey.

Hike, Swim, and Play with Family Near Stewartsville Together

Newest

Luxury rentals

Family-friendly

Swimming

Show on map
Merrill Creek Reservoir

Why Rent On Merrill Creek Reservoir

Merrill Creek Reservoir is a 650-acre lake in Warren County surrounded by 2,000 acres of forest, fields, and wetland that collectively create one of the most ecologically complete natural areas in New Jersey. Built in 1989 to regulate Delaware River water flow, it has become a destination that wildlife enthusiasts, hikers, and anglers consistently rank among the finest in the state. The reservoir’s clarity and the quality of the surrounding trail network put it in a category above most New Jersey lakes of comparable size.

Trails, Fishing, and the Montana Mountain Viewshed

The trail network covers the full perimeter of the reservoir and extends into the surrounding woodlands, ranging from easy lakeside walks to more demanding routes with genuine elevation gain. Montana Mountain, reachable by trail from the reservoir, is one of the most reliable hawk migration watch sites in the state, with broadwing hawk counts during fall migration that regularly reach into the thousands on good weather days.

The Visitor Center and Bird-Feeding Station

The Merrill Creek Visitor Center houses engaging natural history exhibits, an auditorium for programming, and a bird-feeding station that draws a remarkable variety of species throughout the year. Families with younger children find the exhibits accessible and well-designed, and the center’s staff offer environmental education programs that give lake visits an educational dimension that is genuinely worthwhile.

Millbrook Village and the Pohatcong Arboretum

The historic Millbrook Village in the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area is a short drive from the reservoir and preserves a 19th-century rural community with working demonstrations of period crafts and trades. The Pohatcong Native Arboretum adds a botanical layer to the area’s natural programming, focusing specifically on plant species native to the Delaware River watershed.

A Warren County Retreat With Environmental Depth

A vacation rental near Merrill Creek Reservoir gives your family a base in one of New Jersey’s most environmentally significant and visually beautiful landscapes. Properties with wooded surroundings, full kitchens, and outdoor space for wildlife watching put your family inside the natural character of western New Jersey in a way that no hotel can replicate.

Best time to go
Visit Merrill Creek Reservoir in late summer, when the golden sun dances upon the water’s surface. August invites serene fishing excursions and invigorating kayaking, while the crowds diminish. Delight in the tranquility of nature’s embrace, enriched by exquisite sunsets.
Water Quality
Merrill Creek Reservoir's water exhibits a deep blue hue, reflecting its substantial depth of 225 feet, making it the deepest man-made lake in New Jersey. The water is crystal-clear, offering excellent visibility for fishing and boating activities.
Surface area (mi)
1.62
Max depth (ft)
225
Elevation (ft)
926.51
Shoreline length (mi)
7

Popular activities

  • Boating
  • Waterskiing
  • Fishing
  • Ice Skating
pencil

Planning a trip?

Tell us about your upcoming trip and how we can help!

Marinas on Merrill Creek Reservoir

Nearby lakes

Frequently Asked Questions

Ready to dive into what Merrill Creek Reservoir has to offer? Let’s tackle some of the burning questions you might have as you plan your visit!

  • No, swimming is not allowed at Merrill Creek Reservoir. Swimming, wading, and diving are all prohibited activities to ensure visitor safety and protect the environment.

  • Merrill Creek Reservoir is a popular destination because it offers a 650-acre reservoir and over 2,000 acres of forests and fields for outdoor activities. Visitors can enjoy hiking, fishing, boating, and nature study, as well as explore the interactive exhibits at the Visitor’s Center. The area also provides breathtaking panoramas from Montana Mountain.

  • Fishing is not allowed on any of the dikes or from the dam at Merrill Creek Reservoir. Shore fishing is only permitted in designated areas. Additionally, all visitors must be off the property by the posted closing times.

  • There is no public beach at Merrill Creek Reservoir. Swimming is not allowed, and the area is primarily used for fishing, boating, and hiking. The reservoir focuses on low-impact recreational activities and environmental preservation.

  • Merrill Creek Reservoir is located near Harmony Township in Warren County, New Jersey. It is also close to the Warren County Fairgrounds and the hamlet on Montana Mountain. The reservoir is accessible via Fox Farm Road, just south of the fairgrounds.